Some artists build careers that unfold like stories. Early experiments give way to breakthroughs, stylistic detours, and the occasional surprising comeback. The Artist Rankings series explores those stories by looking closely at an artist’s entire discography.
These essays rank albums from beginning to end, but the goal isn’t just to crown a winner. Ranking a catalog can reveal how an artist evolves, how different records speak to one another, and how reputation sometimes shifts over time. A misunderstood album might sound better decades later. A once-beloved release might feel strangely distant.
From classic rock legends to art-pop innovators and cult favorites, the rankings here are designed for listeners who enjoy revisiting albums and debating the shape of a career.
Start Here
Every Marvin Gaye Album Ranked: From Least Essential to Timeless
Every Sade Album Ranked (From Least Essential to Best)
Kate Bush Albums Ranked: From Lionheart to Hounds of Love
Ranking Doja Cat’s Albums: From Internet Irony to Artistic Fire
Browse All Rankings
-
Every Sade Album Ranked (From Least Essential to Best)
Sade’s discography presents a strange challenge. There are only six studio albums. None of them are bad. None of them feel rushed or shout for attention. And yet,… Continue Reading
-
Every Madonna Album Ranked (From Least Essential to Best)
Madonna has one of the strangest careers in pop because she is somehow both overexposed and underheard. Everybody knows the image. Everybody knows the eras. Everybody knows the… Continue Reading
-
The Best Contemporary Albums by ’80s Artists
A Ranking of Reinvention, Not Nostalgia (2010s–Present) There’s a familiar narrative attached to artists who emerged in the 1980s. That they embody the sound of that decade and… Continue Reading
-
The Bob Dylan Albums That Changed How He Could Be Heard: A Ranking of Reinvention
A Ranking of Reinvention, Not Output Trying to rank Bob Dylan albums by quality is a losing game. There are too many records, too many voices, too many… Continue Reading
-
Kate Bush Albums Ranked: From Lionheart to Hounds of Love
Kate Bush has one of the strangest and most self-contained careers in popular music. She arrived fully formed, following her curiosity instead of trends. There are no reinvention… Continue Reading
-
Ranking Sly and the Family Stone: From the Forgotten to the Forever
There’s something that happens when you first really hear Sly and the Family Stone. Something in your chest loosens. Something in your mood lifts. Something in the world… Continue Reading